Sunday, September 9, 2007

tHe diSappOiNtmEnt

I went away from tutorial thinking about the Christmas design. It feels like it would be kind of "forced" if I used presents to illustrate one letter, lightings to represent another. So i decided to change the whole design. What I shall replace it with I hav no idea, but i knew I had to keep thinking about it. In a way, it was like my java programming, only when i constantly think about the problem will ideas and solutions pop up in my head. I didn't hav to wait long when the idea of using chess came across my mind while i was reading an article about chess itself.

I knew i couldn't just use the chess pieces to make up my name as it would be the same design problem as my soccer balls design. So, i decided to illustrate gameplay and in the meantime, showing my name. After much difficulty, I digged up my old Chinese Chess set and started to
place the pieces to make up my name.

One difficulty i faced is the lack of pieces to make up my name, but immediately i had a solution, that is to use the hand to make it look like a letter of my name. That would solve everything. But then, there was the lack of space on the board. To solve this, I made my letters be readable in an anti-clockwise direction so people viewing it wouldn't have much difficulty identifying my name. I took many pictures of the actual Chess set to ensure that the name was visible.



oNe of my earLiEr expErimeNts

























fiNaL iMagE



After several days of sketching and drawing, I finally came up with my design on A5 paper.


rEjeCted cHeSs dEsigN

I was extremely satisfied with it. Not only because I put in many hours of work into it, but also because when i showed people my design, they had no problems identifying my name. I was well aware of the fact that friends will find it easier to recognise my name, so I did ask people whom didn't know me. Although it wasn't as straightforward as my friends, more than half were able to recognise the name.

So, i was very disappointed in tutorial when my work was rejected outrightly. I felt that the tutor was critising it for the sake of criticising it only. Many a times, he rushed through presentations and it just seems to me he rejected my work because he wants to rush for time. Countless hours of hardwork just down the drain with a single sentence. Basically, throughout the tutorial I was very quiet. I was too demoralised to even make a single comment.Not once did the 20% tutorial participation bothered me.

fiNaL soCcEr dEsigN

After some thinking throughout the week and thought i was pretty dumb to feel that way. In many ways, my tutor had much more experience than me, or anyone whom I hav shown the design to. What he feels is probably right, and if he says it isn't good enough, then it probably isn't. He's a teacher and I don't think I should doubt his professionalism in conducting classes.
Think i got too emotional.. But no matter what, I still had to come up with another design and i decided it was best to stick to the Christmas theme. I worked on it, and finally came up with this piece of work which I feel is good enough to be handed in.

Anyway, the other assignments are coming in thick and fast.. I really don't have anymore time to dwell on it.. but a thought lingers on in me.. "why bother to put in so much effort.. when you don't get rewarded for it?"

Well, not everything's bad. The important thing was that I didn't exactly fell so in love with my initial concept that I wasn't willing to change it. At least that's one postivie I can take from this assignment.

2 comments:

erae said...

Hey, thinks the tutor didnt reject your idea, he said your concept'll work better if it's a single alphabet as it complicates with more. So if you can abbreviate your name, I think the chess design'll work perfectly~

And personally I think the brainstorm/designing process is rewarding itself so don't be disheartened eh. Efforts are shown thru your blog reads (so I believe the tutor will see them too)

..and lol, saw your comments regarding my stuff in prev entry, thank you eh XD

gEraLd said...

haha.. is it.. in my impression, he like just wave it off lor.. haha.. but abbreviating seems like playing cheat to me.. haha.. i also duno wor..

guess i'll have to check with julian.. but thanx for ur feedback!!